英语辩论Are holidays become too commercial？

三位辩论者通过假期是否变得商业化这一主题开始辩论，导图中写下了他们的观点以及论述过程，通过客观及主观的观点进行观点论述。

Listening 4.6,4.7,4.8 Are holidays become too commercial?

Speaker one(4.6)

Holidays are one kind of costume (Any holidays are changed recently?)

Speaker one(4.7)

Disagree with opinion1,2&3: Too commercial? she disagree. She like giving gift. She think that giving gifts is a way that shows you are thinking of someone.(this is opinion 4)

Disagree with opinion 5: She thinks that choosing gift need time and need to get something thoughtful, personal.(this is opinion 6)

Disagree with opinion 9: She doubted that the graduation will be happy without gifts, she thinks that graduation gifts are practical.

Give out a question(this is opinion 10): Don't people need gifts and money to start a new life? And when that people look at the gift, he/she will think of who gave him/her the gift.

opinion11: She thinks the custom of giving gift is a good tradition.

Speaker two(4.6)

Talk about Mother's Day in two days

Hasn't brought a gift

Agree with opinion1: Get tired of giving gift, don't know why people need to give a gift for any tiny little holiday.

opinion2: Why mother can't just be happy as we spend time with them, for example, taking them along to a good restaurant.

opinion3: How did the tradition of giving gifts begin, it seems silly to him.

Speaker two(4.7)

Disagree with opinion four: Everyone buy gift because it is an obligation, not because people really want to.(This is opinion 5)

Couldn't agree more with opinion 7: He think that not just holidays, also other special occasions, for example the graduation of his sister, his sister got a lot of gift in money too, he think it's just about opening gifts. (This is opinion 8)

opinion 9: He heard that when someone received more than a few gifts he or she even can't remember who gave them the gift. Instead, why not write letter for advise for the future, it will be more special.

Speaker three(4.6)

Hasn't brought a gift for mother either

opinion1: Who have time to buy a gift for mother when they have too many work to do

Agree with opinion3: That is, that's what their topic: How holidays become too commercial.

Speaker three(4.7)

Not convinced with opinion 6: Buying gifts need to spend money money which can be spent on more important things. Also the time you are shopping can be spent on.Shopping with the person you are shopping for.(This is opinion 7)

Agree with opinion 9: She think that opinion 9 is a great idea.

Still really not convinced with opinion11......

HELEN